Skip to main content
Hijacked on Paper: Defending Shareholders Against Invalid Share Transfers

News

Hijacked on Paper: Defending Shareholders Against Invalid Share Transfers

All news & events

Avon Chambers represents original shareholders in a dispute involving invalid share transfers and an alleged takeover of a private company. The matter, currently before the High Court Division, concerns rectification of the company’s register of members under Section 43 of the Companies Act, 1994.

A recent matter before the High Court Division shows how an out-of-date register of members can be used to stage a takeover of a private company, and how original shareholders can use Section 43 of the Companies Act, 1994 to put the register right.

KEY TAKEAWAY: A shareholder who has already transferred their shares has nothing left to transfer. Fresh transfer documents executed on the strength of an old register pass no title. Section 43 allows the High Court Division to correct the register and to decide who really owns the shares.

Chambers Note

Avon Chambers advised and represents a family of original shareholders whose company was taken over on paper by its former shareholders. We advised the family to bring an application under Section 43 of the Companies Act, 1994 for rectification of the company’s register of members and of the corresponding records held by the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms. We have also been advising on the connected civil and criminal proceedings, so that the family’s position is protected on every front.

The Dispute in Simple Terms

More than two decades ago, our clients acquired the entire share capital of a private limited company. Every outgoing shareholder signed a share transfer instrument. The Board approved the transfers on the same day, the former directors resigned, and the family took over the management of the company.

The company’s annual returns, however, continued to list the old shareholders. Years later, two of those former shareholders held a purported Board meeting. Relying on shares they had transferred long before, they executed fresh transfer documents in favour of new persons and installed a new Managing Director. The new management then obtained a court order deleting our clients’ filings at the Registrar, in a proceeding to which our clients were never made parties.

On paper, the company had changed hands. In law, it had not.

What Is Rectification Under Section 43?

The register of members is the company’s record of who its shareholders are. It is evidence of membership; it is not the source of ownership. Ownership comes from the transfer itself.

Section 43 allows the High Court Division to order the register to be corrected where a person’s name has been entered or omitted without sufficient cause, or where there has been default or delay in entering a change. The Court may also decide any question of title to the shares that arises in the application. This makes Section 43 a direct route to the heart of a shareholding dispute, without a separate civil suit.

The Core Argument: You Cannot Transfer What You No Longer Own

Our clients’ case was straightforward. The former shareholders had transferred every one of their shares more than twenty years earlier. Whatever the annual returns said, they had nothing left to sell. Any document they later signed purporting to transfer those same shares was ineffective, and so was every step built on it, including the purported change of directors and management.

In practical terms, the family’s position was that:

  • the original transfers were complete, approved by the Board and acted upon;
  • the later transfers were made by persons who no longer held the shares;
  • the delay in updating the statutory records was a reason to correct them, not a defence for those who exploited them, since Section 43 itself provides for default or delay in recording a transfer; and
  • an order obtained in proceedings to which the true shareholders were not parties could not decide who owned the shares.

Why This Matters for Shareholders

Paper takeovers usually succeed through neglect rather than cleverness. Family-owned and closely held companies are especially exposed. Records are often left to accountants, annual returns are filed out of habit, and nobody checks whether the register still matches reality until a stranger turns up claiming control.

Original shareholders can protect themselves by:

  • Checking the RJSC records regularly. The latest annual return (Schedule X) and Form XII should reflect the true shareholding and directorship.
  • Keeping the original documents safe. Share transfer instruments, Board minutes, resignation letters and share certificates are the evidence that wins these cases.
  • Acting on the first warning sign. An unexpected Form XII, a meeting you weren’t told about, or a filing you didn’t make all call for prompt legal advice. Once shares change hands again, they become harder to reach.
  • Not relying on the register alone. Title rests on the documents, and a register that is wrong can be corrected to match them.

Where the Matter Stands

The rectification application is before the High Court Division. We continue to advise the family on the application and the connected criminal and civil proceedings.

The original shareholders are represented by Barrister Asif Bin Anwar, assisted by Barrister Nazifa Sarwar.

Related legal services

Keep reading

More from Chambers

Book a consultation

Tell us what happened. We'll tell you where you stand.

Initial consultations are 45 minutes and held with the partner who would lead your matter.

Direct line
+880 1841-010059
Office
Flat 4A, Level 3, Kanak Bindu, House 39A, Road No. 8
Dhanmondi, Dhaka 1205
Confidentiality
Everything you send is treated as privileged and confidential, whether or not we go on to represent you.

Get in touch

Message our team on WhatsApp and we’ll respond as soon as we can.

Contact us on WhatsApp

Follow us